Our Verdict: MetLife Pet Insurance (2026)

MetLife Pet Insurance earns 4.5 out of 5 stars for its unmatched combination of a 0-day accident waiting period, multi-pet Family Plan, and Fortune 100 financial backing. It is especially compelling for employees whose workplace offers a group discount. With average premiums of $57/month for dogs and $36/month for cats, it is competitively priced relative to coverage depth. The main trade-offs: no accident-only plan, and claims occasionally require more documentation than competitors like Lemonade.

About MetLife Pet Insurance

MetLife Pet Insurance was launched after MetLife acquired PetFirst Healthcare in 2020 and rebranded the product under its name. MetLife, Inc. is one of the largest global insurers (Fortune 500), and that institutional backing matters: the company offers financial strength ratings of A+ (Superior) from AM Best and handles millions of claims annually. Today, MetLife Pet is sold both directly to consumers and through employer benefit programs — where it competes directly with dental and vision insurance as a voluntary benefit. Coverage is underwritten by Independence American Insurance Company (IAIC) or Metropolitan General Insurance Company, depending on your state.

MetLife Pet Insurance Plans

MetLife offers one core plan type — Accident & Illness — with optional preventive care add-ons and a unique Family Plan for multi-pet households. Unlike several competitors, MetLife does not offer an accident-only plan; all policies include illness coverage by default.

Accident & Illness Coverage

The core plan covers a wide range of conditions: injuries, illnesses, cancer, chronic conditions, hereditary and congenital conditions (with no age restrictions), diagnostic tests (X-rays, MRIs, bloodwork), surgeries, hospitalizations, alternative therapies (acupuncture, hydrotherapy, physical therapy), and behavioral issues. Coverage also includes grief counseling benefits if a pet passes away — a thoughtful feature not commonly offered. You can customize your policy with deductibles from $0 to $2,500, reimbursement rates of 70%, 80%, or 90%, and annual limits of $2,000, $5,000, $10,000, or Unlimited.

Preventive Care Add-Ons

MetLife offers two optional wellness plans for routine care: the Preventative 365 plan ($365 in annual preventive care coverage) and the Preventive 575 plan (up to $575 in coverage). These cover routine vet visits, vaccines, dental cleanings, flea/tick prevention, spay/neuter, and more. Preventive care coverage activates on Day 1 of your policy — no waiting period.

The Family Plan

MetLife's signature feature is the Family Plan, which lets you insure up to three dogs or cats on a single policy with a shared deductible and shared annual limit. This simplifies billing (one premium, one deductible to meet) and is especially cost-effective when pets are healthy — once any pet satisfies the household deductible, all pets are covered for the rest of the year. A unique rollover benefit applies: if you have at least $5,000 in annual coverage and $1,000 or more goes unused at year-end, MetLife automatically adds $500 in coverage for the following policy term at no extra cost.

Employer-Sponsored Group Plans

MetLife is one of the few pet insurers that actively distributes through workplace benefits programs. Over 70% of full-time employees own at least one pet, and hundreds of employers — from universities (Stanford, Penn State) to corporations (Sysco, Microsoft benefits programs) — offer MetLife Pet as a voluntary benefit. Enrolling through your employer gives you an automatic 10% group discount on premiums (5% for affinity groups). Premiums are deducted directly from your paycheck. Enrollment is open year-round — not restricted to annual open enrollment periods. Importantly, if you leave your employer, your policy is portable: you continue paying MetLife directly.

How Much Does MetLife Pet Insurance Cost?

MetLife's premiums vary significantly by pet species, age, breed, and zip code. Here are the key benchmarks:

Dogs average $57/month ($684/year)
Cats average $36/month ($437/year)
Entry-level plans start at $16/month for dogs, $7/month for cats
Cat premiums range by state: $25/month (Arkansas) to $48/month (Massachusetts)
Deductible options: $0 to $2,500 annually — higher deductible lowers your monthly premium
Reimbursement: 70%, 80%, or 90% of covered vet costs

Employer enrollment adds a 10% discount on top of the standard rate. Additional discounts are available for military/veterans, healthcare workers, and first responders. MetLife's pricing is generally competitive relative to its coverage depth — reviewers from Bankrate and MoneyGeek both rate MetLife's cost-to-value ratio above average for its category.

MetLife Employer Pet Insurance: How It Works

If your employer offers MetLife Pet as a benefit, here is how to find out and enroll: Ask your HR department whether MetLife Pet Insurance is included in voluntary benefits. If it is, you can enroll at any time during the year — not just during open enrollment. Premiums are deducted from your paycheck automatically.

One significant advantage of the employer route: MetLife may waive pre-existing condition exclusions for conditions already covered by your previous pet insurer, provided there is no lapse in coverage. This is the Pre-Existing Condition Waiver Endorsement, and it is only available to employer plan enrollees switching from another insurer. For employees who already pay for pet insurance elsewhere, this waiver alone can justify switching to MetLife through their benefits package. Coverage begins on the first of the month following enrollment.

What MetLife Covers — and What It Doesn't

MetLife's Accident & Illness plan is comprehensive, but knowing the exclusions helps avoid surprises at claim time.

Covered

Accidents and injuries (effective same day — midnight on enrollment date)
Illnesses including cancer, diabetes, arthritis, and chronic conditions (14-day waiting period)
Hereditary and congenital conditions — with no age restrictions or breed exclusions
Diagnostic tests: X-rays, MRIs, ultrasounds, bloodwork
Surgeries, hospitalizations, and specialist visits
Alternative therapies: acupuncture, hydrotherapy, physical therapy
Orthopedic conditions: no separate waiting period (unlike many competitors who impose 6-month waits)
Exotic pets: birds, reptiles, rabbits, and ferrets
Grief counseling benefit if a pet passes away

Not Covered

Pre-existing conditions (incurable chronic conditions excluded; curable conditions may be covered if a subsequent incident is clinically unrelated)
Elective or cosmetic procedures
Breeding, pregnancy, or whelping costs
Grooming, boarding, or training
Prescription food and supplements (unless prescribed for a covered illness)

Important: MetLife does not require medical records at enrollment. However, when you file your first claim, MetLife will request the last 12 months of vet records (or adoption paperwork) to review for pre-existing conditions. Claims must be filed within 90 days of treatment. Unlike some competitors, MetLife does not apply a specific look-back window for curable conditions — instead, it reviews whether a subsequent illness is clinically related to a prior one. If your dog had an ear infection before coverage and develops an unrelated ear infection after, the second claim would likely be covered.

How to File a MetLife Pet Insurance Claim

MetLife allows you to visit any licensed vet, emergency clinic, or specialist in the US — there is no in-network requirement. Here is the claims process:

Step 1: Pay your vet bill upfront at the time of service
Step 2: Submit your claim through the MetLife Pet app, online portal, email, fax, or mail
Step 3: Include the itemized vet invoice and any medical records requested
Step 4: Claims are typically processed within 5–10 business days
Step 5: Reimbursement is issued by direct deposit or check for covered expenses

First-time claimants should expect MetLife to request 12 months of prior vet records. Subsequent claims are usually faster once your pet's history is on file. The mobile app (available on iOS and Android) is the fastest route — users report uploading photos of invoices directly from the exam room.

MetLife Pet Insurance Reviews: What Customers Say

MetLife Pet Insurance holds a 4.7 out of 5 star rating on Trustpilot from over 7,300 verified reviews. Positive reviews most frequently highlight the claims process — particularly ease of submission through the app and reimbursement speeds. Many customers report receiving direct deposits within one to two weeks. MetLife holds a BBB rating of A- and ranks eighth nationally for customer experience among pet insurers. The most common criticism on platforms like Reddit and Consumer Affairs centers on claims that require multiple rounds of documentation before approval, and occasional slow processing periods during peak times.

What Reddit Says About MetLife Pet Insurance

The most active Reddit thread on MetLife — frequently appearing at position 2 in search results for "metlife pet insurance" — is titled "Is MetLife pet insurance really worth it or just a scam?" in r/petinsurancereviews. The consensus is nuanced: MetLife is not a scam, but policyholders with older pets or pets with prior health history report more friction at claim time due to pre-existing condition reviews. Policyholders who enrolled young, healthy pets and have used MetLife for years report very positive outcomes — citing approved claims for surgeries, cancer treatment, and emergency visits. The employer discount is a recurring reason people choose MetLife over competitors.

Pros and Cons

Pros

0-day accident waiting period — coverage starts at midnight on enrollment date
No upper age limit and no breed exclusions
Family Plan covers up to 3 pets on one policy with a shared deductible
10% group discount when enrolling through employer
Covers exotic pets: birds, reptiles, rabbits, and ferrets
30-day money-back guarantee (no claims filed)
Unused coverage rollover: auto $500 increase if $1,000+ goes unused on a $5,000+ plan
Pre-existing condition waiver available when switching via employer plan

Cons

No accident-only plan — all policies include illness coverage
Incurable pre-existing conditions permanently excluded
First claim requires 12 months of prior vet records
Premiums can increase at renewal
Online quote tool can be difficult to navigate for coverage details

MetLife vs. Competitors

MetLife is most competitive against Nationwide and ASPCA for multi-pet households and employer plan buyers. Versus Lemonade: MetLife wins on coverage breadth and employer accessibility; Lemonade wins on claims speed (often 2-day payouts via AI) and app experience. Versus Spot: MetLife's Family Plan is unique; Spot offers unlimited annual coverage per pet, which may be better for high-risk multi-pet homes. Versus Embrace: Both cover orthopedic conditions without extended waiting periods; Embrace offers a "Healthy Pet Deductible" that reduces your deductible by $50 each year you don't file a claim. Versus ASPCA: Both offer solid A&I coverage; MetLife has the edge for employer plan availability and exotic pet coverage.

Who MetLife Pet Insurance Is Best For

Employees whose company offers MetLife Pet as a voluntary benefit (10% group discount + portability)
Multi-pet households (2–3 pets) who want simplified billing under the Family Plan
Owners of senior pets — no upper age limit makes MetLife one of few options for older animals
Owners switching from another insurer who want pre-existing conditions waived (employer route only)
Military, veterans, healthcare workers, and first responders (additional discounts available)
Exotic pet owners — birds, reptiles, rabbits, and ferrets are covered

How to Get a Quote or Enroll

Check with your HR department — if your employer offers MetLife Pet, you can enroll at any time (not just open enrollment)
Visit metlifepetinsurance.com or call 1-800-438-6388 to get a direct quote in about 2 minutes
Customize your plan: choose deductible ($0–$2,500), reimbursement rate (70/80/90%), and annual limit
Add the Preventative 365 or Preventive 575 wellness plan for routine care coverage
Coverage for accidents begins at midnight on your enrollment date; illness coverage starts after 14 days

MetLife Pet Insurance